Shift Ministry Models

A Fresh Vision in Stewarding

Don’t talk to me about stewardship as if it is this thing I do. Talk to me about how I am a steward.
by Center for Stewardship Leaders | March 13, 2019

A blog post by Jonathan Davis

I have this theory. Sometimes I wonder if theology and ministry are just like fashion — it’s all about what’s trendy.

I listen to a lot of sermons. It seems that sermons on the same text over the years shift in focus and theology because we grow tired of the old ways. Sermons on the parable of the Prodigal Son years ago focused on the wayward son who squandered everything. But then it shifted to the older brother. Nowadays, we are drawn to the father and his wasteful and gracious love.                                    

Do you see? We grow tired of one interpretation and so we move on to another, just like we grow tired of one trend and move on to another. Years ago, baggy clothes were trendy. Now, it’s all about the slim cut.

I can’t help but wonder if stewardship has the same problem. That there isn’t any real foundation to it — it is just whether it is novel and interesting. For a while, we all knew that the topic of “stewardship” at church meant talking about money and if we could give more. But we grew tired of that. So then, we were told that stewardship isn’t just about money. Rather, it’s about our whole life. Our time, talents, and treasures. But even this is starting to feel a little dated to me, a little worn out.

But then, a couple years ago, I heard the best stewardship talk of my life when I attended Mercy Seat. Pastors Mark and Kae shared how they loved Mercy Seat, but for it to continue, the church needed X-amount of money. They gave us a tangible number needed for 100 people to give each week. Finally, they asked if we would consider being one of those 100 people. It seemed so simple! Many people giving a little can do a lot. I wasn’t invited to pray about how much God was calling me to give back. I wasn’t given a blank pledge card to put down any number on. I was asked if I could give a specific amount. I could wrap my arms and my mind around that.

When I sat down to write about stewardship, I had nothing. So, I reread the email inviting me to blog about this and as it turns out, I wasn’t asked to write about stewardship. I was asked to write on being a steward. For some reason, stewardship and being a steward seemed like two entirely different things to me. One felt complex, boring, and even a little annoying. The other felt new, fresh, and uncharted. It was like I traded in that old, baggy sweatshirt for a new, slim cut, plaid dress shirt. Stewardship feels like something that is done to me or something I am asked to do myself. But talk of being a steward feels so embodied. Not something I do, but something I am. It’s about part of my identity.

There is something about being called a steward that gets me thinking more creatively about money and how we use it. For example, by my rough calculations, did you know that if every member of the ELCA gave $2 a year, ELCA seminarians wouldn’t have to pay tuition? Or did you know that if my congregation gave away 10% of the $6,000 savings from my new health insurance plan, we can erase the $600/per year increase to one of my fellow pastor’s insurance plan?

That sort of creative thinking about money — where many people doing a little can accomplish a lot — is interesting. It holds my attention. And it comes from thinking of myself more as a steward rather than doing stewardship.

So, how do we raise up stewards? I suspect it begins with the youngest ones among us. We seem to keep money out of the hands of our children for as long as we can. Nathan Dungan thinks we should be putting money into the hands of our children around the same age we give them books. I agree. To raise up stewards, let’s start putting money in the hands of children and start teaching them how to use it creatively for the sake of a better world.

After all, it isn’t our money, it’s God’s. We aren’t called to do stewardship, we are called to be stewards. So, that’s my vote for the next trend in stewardship, folks. Don’t talk to me about stewardship as if it is this thing that I do. Talk to me about how I am a steward. How it is about who I am, and who God calls me to be.

Author Bio:
Jonathan Davis is a Lutheran pastor living in Northfield, Minn. He is the Associate Pastor at St. John’s Lutheran Church

Post first published on on Nov. 19, 2013

About the Author

Center for Stewardship Leaders

The Center for Stewardship Leaders seeks to shape a faithful, multidimensional culture of stewardship in congregations, households, and society. The center strives to consider the full spectrum of stewardship practice and theology, including financial stewardship, holistic stewardship, and leadership. See all posts from CSL.

Upcoming Learning Experiences

Don't Miss an Insight

Get The Faith+Leader delivered directly to your inbox.

Unsubscribe anytime. We'll never rent or share your information.